Ingenious abilities basically articulates one's capability of being able to have the necessary power to accomplish something.
However, there's a fine line between being able to have the necessary power to accomplish something and having the potential to accomplish something.
For countless years, Ken Holland, the mastermind behind the Detroit Red Wings, has had all the resources to complete franchise-changing signings and impressive trades. Whether it might be trading for one of the best U.S. born defenders in NHL history in Chris Chelios or acquiring Brett Hull as a free agent for a successful Stanley Cup run in 2002, Holland has been continuously heralded for his general manager skills. Even after the infamous NHL lockout in 2005 with the salary cap coming into motion, he was still capable of luring in elite players, such as Brian Rafalski and Marian Hossa.
Through a hockey era where accuracy and timing is key, Holland has proved to be among the best of the best; however, in recent times, a lack of "cream of the crop" acquisitions mystifies Holland's flawless methods. One could suggest it all began with the retirement of Rafalski, a great right-handed defenseman who accented the play of Nicklas Lidstrom and made the Red Wings powerplay one of the best in the league. Once he announced his surprising retirement due to accumulated injuries, Holland was left with several options prior to free agency. James Wisniewski and Christian Ehrhoff were both becoming unrestricted free agents and were just the type of defensemen that could provide significant depth on Detroit's blueline. The Columbus Blue Jackets pounced on Wisniewski , trading for his negotiating rights before he even hit July 1st. The Buffalo Sabres pulled the same move with Ehrhoff. Both players would end up with mediocre seasons, somewhat justifying Holland's acquisition of Ian White. 1st wave of difficulty? Pass.
This offseason has arguably proved to be the most complicated of Ken Holland's career where he was put into a situation that consisted of the inevitable departure of vital players. Nicklas Lidstrom respectfully chose retirement, Brad Stuart fled to San Jose due to family reasons; the two best defencemen on the Red Wings. Gone. Jiri Hudler took a season filled with a career-high 25 goals to the Calgary Flames. That's about 10% of the Red Wings 239 goals scored in the 2011-2012 season. That's a pretty big number if you don't replace it.
"We're going to be active and very involved in free agency because we have cap space and holes we'd like to fill." The words of Holland, a GM in need of addressing the desire for depth among the forwards and bringing in defensive talent to acknowledge the absence of Lidstrom and Stuart. The Red Wings have inked goaltender Jonas Gustavsson, forward agitator Jordin Tootoo and veteran Mikael Samuelsson. Was this the answer fans were looking for?
The true frustration comes out of the failure to land a premium upgrade on defense with around $13 million in cap space. Holland and the Wings' management were "..right there until the end" for defenseman Ryan Suter, according to the man himself. Despite pursuing him as soon as free agency began, he chose the Minnesota Wild. The next available "high-class" defenseman was Matt Carle, he chose the Lightning. Jason Garrison chose the Canucks. Decent options became much fewer.
Nashville Predators captain Shea Weber had talks with Detroit, but Holland was never presented with the option to sign him to an offer sheet, so the Philadelphia Flyers did. Another opportunity missed.
Trade talks? The Red Wings couldn't make their pitches for Rick Nash or Shea Weber because Detroit's division rivals wouldn't want their own players excelling in the Motor City for many years to come. It's almost portrayed as excuse after excuse for every possible option out there for Ken Holland. If an individual were to look at Detroit's current roster, they could suggest the offensive group is somewhat established for a playoff run in a sense though there's no clear view of taking a step forward in terms of youth. Taking a view at the defence core, there's nothing too thrilling about unit a consisting of Kronwall, White, Quincey, Ericsson, Kindl and Smith with the obvious exceptions being Kronwall and possibly the young Smith. Quincey has a lot to prove after last season whereas Kindl has yet to blossom and White is simply a powerplay specialist. In terms of Ericsson, if he's proclaimed to be the number one shut-down defenseman, then there's obviously a need for an actual shut-down defenseman.
If this is the realistic approach the Red Wings are taking with their current roster then Ken Holland's skills as a general manager in the NHL can quite possibly be questioned. Is the question purely based around bad luck in this offseason or has he really lost his touch? He definitely hasn't lost his natural ability, but one cannot sit on past accomplishments and victories forever, relying on them to set pace for the future.
Ken Holland has six weeks to set his tools in motion. Does it mean acquiring a top-2 defenseman and a top shut-down defenseman? Yes. Does it mean adding a top-six forward like Shane Doan or Bobby Ryan? Yes. Is all this possible? It definitely is, but it is quite difficult for any GM around the NHL to pull off such an immense task to make their team number one.
Even with all these endeavours that lay ahead for Holland, there's a few things that can be said. Ken Holland's contributions towards the Detroit Red Wings will always be put into question, whether they be positive or negative; however, Holland has made his mark. No will ever be able to take away what he's brought to this franchise, leaving the age of the "Dead Wings" era behind. Now, the question that comes into play is can he avoid that era again?
very insightful take on the red wings situation, good job!!
ReplyDeleteVery good article. Should have kept Joey MacDonald since he is great and has a one way contract.
ReplyDeleteNicely said! Especially about the cacophony of available excuses for lack of success. You get tired of hearing, "We're happy with the way our team looks". We'll see if he still feels that way after looking up from 11th place in the West this next season. If there is one!
ReplyDeleteI am pretty sure sure with the current roster they will be better than 11th in the west
ReplyDeleteJoe Mac is a liability with his back. His problems do not really just go away or is fixed. 11th in the west? Whatever dude
ReplyDeleteNot trying to be a jerk, but this reads like book report and lacks any real insight or flavor. I migh give you another shot in the future, but this post didn't offer anything that would motivate me to continue reading.
ReplyDeleteTotally disagree with this statement of this article being a "book report." The author is evidently providing two opposing sides from a non-bias view of how Ken Holland has formulated his team over the years. Excellent read.
Delete^ What this guy said; this article is pretty sweet. I honestly see some comprehensive insight, I really don't understand how it reads as a book report. Nicely done, Mathew.
DeleteNice job with this.
ReplyDeleteVerdict should still be out on Wisniewski (would've had 50+ pts in a full season last year) and Erhoff, who both had injury-riddled seasons.
Let's not forget that Wisniewski practiced with the Wings 2 summers in a row and still has residence in Canton. He also has the same agent that Rafalski had, so there were some strong ties to the franchise. His verbal joust at Holland not wanting to overpay was a telling sign to many, in particular when Holland scoffed at it while overpaying Ericsson to keep him in the fold.
There's little doubt in my mind that Wisniewski's right-handed shot on the blue line last season and this upcoming season would've been huge boon for the team. It's another missed opportunity for Holland and further illustration that he's been swimming since Bowman left town in July of 2008.
I think it's more an illustration of how he's been struggling to maintain dominance following the lockout. A great deal of parity has been brought into the league through the salary cap.
DeleteYep, that's a fair take.
DeleteMy pause with acceptance of the parity excuse comes from situations like Garrisson who signed with the Canucks (a roster that is loaded on D) this off-season.
I still think it's fair to conclude that some franchises continue to be exceptions to this rule in the post cap world on an annual basis, hence the Rafalski and Hossa signings some years back.
The biggest contributor to the erosion of the RW perception has been Holland's inability to make any meaningful trades or roster decisions over the past few years to prepare for Lidstrom's and/or Stuart's departure or to react to Rafalski's early retirement.
Most non-eternally optimistic RW faithful are wondering what the vision has been for this franchise for a few years now, and what we're all left with is hoping for the best.
The lone glimmer of hope is that this status of the brand won't be tolerated for very long by Mr. Illitch.
I think it's entirely possible that Holland has been basking in the glory of Lidstrom like the rest of us. And like the rest of us, had convinced himself that this glorious era of Lidstrom would never end.
DeleteI don't blame him for not "preparing" for Rafalski leaving. That was unexpected. And I give Ian White more credit for filling that role than others do.
Mike, there's no doubt that Ken Holland was wishing the day of Nicklas Lidstrom's retirement to never come, but some argue that he wasn't as "prepared" if you will as he should have been. Should he have gone after a defenceman near the same calibre as Nick a year before his retirement? Maybe, as it seems like he was possibly over-confident in his inquiring of Ryan Suter and didn't portray much interest in any other high-end defencemen as many reports suggest.
DeleteI liked the White signing when it happened, it was reasonably priced, he has a right handed shot (ideal for the second PP unit), and he would've been a fine replacement for a 33 year old Brad Stuart as an even-strength second line compliment for a few seasons.
DeleteRafalski will be in the hall of fame one day, at the very least they should've overreacted by landing a legit first pairing dman by spending an extra 500k-1m to land a guy like Wisniewski last summer. If you don't do that, give your best prospect in Smith a season of play so that you (and other players considering your franchise) know exactly what you have heading into this October.
The lack of foresight with the d-position group has put the team in a precarious position for this upcoming season and beyond.
Absolutely agree with what's being said in this article. Ken Holland has definitely achieved some major accomplishments in his career as GM, but that doesn't justify what he's been faced with in this offseason. Hopefully he has a big surprise for us Wings fans. Great post!
ReplyDeleteNicely done, Matt.
ReplyDeleteIts hard to say if Holland has lost his touch but in my personal opinion, no he hasn't.
Suter went to Minny to be with family, can't argue that. So did Parise. Nashville would have matched the offer sheet if Detroit would have signed Weber to one because they wouldn't want to see Weber 6 times a year doing to them what Weber has done to Detroit over the years..same with Columbus with Nash. Its hard to deal with that.
This years free agent crop has was shallow and it has proven that.
Thanks a lot, Chris. That's precisely what came to my mind these past few weeks into July. Ken Holland was put into a situation where he had a ton of money in his hands yet a strong amount of cap space had no effect on free agents. One could easily look at this offseason as bad luck due to family matters and political reasons towards certain players not wearing a Wings jersey this upcoming season.
DeleteGreat article Danam! Very good insight about the Red Wings.
ReplyDeleteThe way you structured two point of views in your article is superb. Great article!! Go Wings!!
ReplyDeleteaye aye
ReplyDeleteLombardi > Holland
ReplyDeleteAriel > Rachel